29 Jun 2025
Thought leadership
Read time: 3 Min
19k

Your Stomach Acid Could Dissolve Metal

By Marc Bates

Human stomach acid hits a pH of 1.5. That's more corrosive than battery acid.

Most people assume this extreme acidity exists to break down plant fibers. They're wrong.

This level of acidity serves one primary purpose: denaturing massive boluses of animal protein and killing the pathogens that come with eating meat. It's the same pH found in carrion-eating animals like hyenas and vultures.

Your digestive system wasn't designed for the foods you've been told are healthy.

The Anatomy of a Meat Eater

Look at human digestive anatomy compared to our closest relatives. The differences tell a story medical schools rarely teach.

The human colon represents only 20% of our total digestive tract volume. In apes, it's 50%.

This matters because large colons are fermentation chambers. They're designed to extract calories and B-vitamins from fibrous plant matter through bacterial breakdown.

We traded that massive fermentation capacity for something else: a proportionally enormous small intestine optimized for absorbing pre-digested nutrients. Amino acids. Fatty acids. The building blocks that come from animal tissue.

Our digestive anatomy resembles obligate carnivores far more than plant-eating primates.

Then there's our brain.

The human brain consumes 20% of our total metabolism. This energy-hungry organ expanded rapidly in our evolutionary history, coinciding with intensified hunting and marrow extraction.

The expensive-tissue hypothesis explains this trade-off: we shrunk our gut to fuel our brain. But this only works if your diet is calorie-dense, nutrient-rich, and low in toxins.

That describes animal foods perfectly.

The Plant Defense Problem

Plants don't want to be eaten. They've evolved sophisticated chemical warfare to prevent it.

Take oxalates, found in spinach, almonds, and other "superfoods." When you consume high-oxalate foods, here's what happens in your body:

Within minutes, soluble oxalate ions slip between gut cells, especially when inflammation has weakened tight junctions. Up to 70% of the oxalate load gets absorbed directly into your bloodstream.

These free ions immediately start chelating calcium and magnesium, robbing these essential minerals from enzymes and mitochondria. You might feel muscle twitches or heart palpitations as your electrolyte balance shifts.

Within 2-6 hours, calcium-oxalate crystals begin forming. These microscopic shards pierce cell membranes and rupture mitochondrial walls, creating an energy crisis in vulnerable tissues.

The crystals activate your immune system's danger signals, triggering chronic inflammation that can persist for months or years.

Eventually, these crystals lodge in kidneys, thyroid, arteries, and joints, causing organ-specific damage over time. Kidney stones. Hypothyroidism. Arterial stiffening. Joint pain.

True herbivores possess dedicated enzymes and gut bacteria to neutralize these compounds. We don't.

Our limited plant-detox pathways suggest something crucial: plants were emergency food, not dietary staples.

The Modern Microbiome Crisis

Humans once harbored protective bacteria like Oxalobacter formigenes that could break down oxalates. Most of us have lost these microbial allies.

Broad-spectrum antibiotics wipe out O. formigenes completely. A single 14-day course can eliminate colonization for six months or permanently.

C-section births, chlorinated water, pesticide residues, and ultra-sanitary living have created a perfect storm. Hunter-gatherer populations maintain 80% colonization rates. Urban Americans? About 30%.

Without these protective microbes, plant toxins hit us harder than ever before.

The Recovery Timeline

When people transition from high plant-toxin diets to carnivore approaches, recovery follows a predictable pattern.

**Days 1-3:** Gut permeability begins healing as lectin exposure stops. Oxalate absorption drops 20-40%. Bloating subsides and that "sandy urine" feeling disappears.

**Days 3-14:** Insulin sensitivity improves dramatically. Fasting insulin can drop 35-48% within the first week. Energy stabilizes between meals as the body shifts to fat metabolism.

**Weeks 2-4:** Inflammatory markers cool down. Blood pressure normalizes. Morning joint stiffness fades as systemic inflammation decreases.

**Months 1-3:** Deeper healing occurs. HbA1c falls 0.3-1.0% per 90-day red blood cell cycle. Skin clears. Autoimmune symptoms often improve significantly.

The speed of these changes reveals something important: we're removing dietary stressors our bodies were never designed to handle.

The Clinical Evidence

A large-scale study of 2,029 carnivore diet followers found remarkable results. Participants reported 95% satisfaction with overall health improvements.

Median BMI dropped from 27.2 to 24.3. Those with diabetes saw even more dramatic changes: BMI reductions of 4.3 points, HbA1c improvements of 0.4%, and 84-100% reductions in diabetes medications.

Adverse effects were surprisingly rare, affecting less than 1-5.5% of participants. The clinical data challenges every assumption about plant-based nutrition being inherently healthier.

Traditional populations provide additional evidence. Inuit, Plains Indians, and Maasai thrived for generations on diets providing 70% or more calories from animal sources, displaying robust metabolic health with minimal plant foods.

The Neurological Connection

Animal foods provide nutrients that plant foods simply cannot: carnitine, heme iron, vitamin B12, and preformed DHA.

Carnitine deserves special attention. It's essential for mitochondrial energy production, neurotransmitter synthesis, and brain development. Red meat provides 56-162mg per 100g. Plants provide less than 1mg.

Vegetarian mothers show 20-40% lower carnitine levels. When combined with genetic variants affecting carnitine synthesis, this creates a perfect storm for neurodevelopmental issues.

Clinical trials using carnitine supplementation in autism show 20-26% improvements in social engagement and language within three months. The connection between animal-food nutrients and brain function runs deeper than most realize.

Rethinking Everything

The evidence points to an uncomfortable truth: humans are facultative carnivores who can survive on plants but thrive on animal foods.

We possess the anatomy of meat-eaters. Our digestive chemistry matches carrion feeders. Our brains require nutrients found primarily in animal tissue.

Modern plant-heavy diets may be pushing us beyond our biological limits.

The rising rates of autoimmune disease, kidney stones, and metabolic dysfunction correlate with increased consumption of plant foods marketed as healthy.

This doesn't mean plants are universally harmful. It means we need to recognize our biological constraints.

The Practical Path Forward

Start with data, not ideology.

Track your baseline: three days of honest food logging, basic metabolic panel, and waist measurement. See where you actually stand.

Then run a 30-day experiment. Remove obvious metabolic disruptors: sugar, grains, seed oils, processed foods. Center every meal around nutrient-dense animal foods.

Add plants only if they cause zero digestive or inflammatory response.

Retest your markers after 30 days. Let your biochemistry tell you what works.

Most people see fasting insulin drop, triglyceride-to-HDL ratios improve, and waist circumference shrink. Objective proof that their bodies run better on an animal-forward template.

The goal isn't dietary perfection. It's biological alignment.

Your anatomy evolved over millions of years. Your current diet probably didn't.

Maybe it's time to let evolution guide your next meal.

media-contact-avatar
CONTACT DETAILS

Email for questions

marc@optimalhumandiet.com

NEWSLETTER

Receive news by email

Press release
Company updates
Thought leadership

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply

You have successfully subscribed to the news!

Something went wrong!